Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
The role of advertising in contemporary society has become a subject of considerable debate. While some argue that it remains a highly effective tool for influencing consumer behaviour, others contend that its ubiquity has rendered it largely ineffective. This essay will discuss both perspectives before concluding that, despite its pervasiveness, advertising continues to exert a significant impact on purchasing decisions.
On the one hand, those who believe that advertising has lost its power have compelling reasons. In today's media-saturated world, consumers are exposed to thousands of commercial messages daily through television, social media, billboards, and websites. This sheer volume of advertising has led to what is commonly termed "ad fatigue," where people become desensitised and simply ignore promotional content. Furthermore, the rise of ad-blocking software and subscription-based streaming services has enabled consumers to actively circumvent advertisements. Many people have also become more sceptical of marketing claims, having been repeatedly exposed to exaggerated or misleading promotions. For instance, the proliferation of influencer marketing has made audiences more aware of sponsored content, often causing them to dismiss such endorsements as inauthentic.
On the other hand, proponents of advertising's efficacy present a persuasive counter-argument. The global advertising industry continues to grow exponentially, with companies investing billions annually, which would be irrational if advertising were truly ineffective. Moreover, the advent of digital advertising has enabled unprecedented levels of personalisation, allowing marketers to target specific demographics with tailored messages based on browsing history and purchasing behaviour. This precision ensures that advertisements reach those most likely to be interested, thereby increasing their effectiveness. For example, the success of platforms like Google and Meta, whose business models are fundamentally reliant on advertising revenue, demonstrates that brands continue to derive substantial value from such investments. Even when consumers claim to ignore ads, subtle brand exposure through repeated viewing can create familiarity and influence subconscious preferences, a phenomenon known as the mere exposure effect.
In my estimation, while it is true that traditional forms of advertising may have diminished in impact, advertising as a whole remains extraordinarily effective. The key distinction lies in the evolution of advertising techniques rather than their obsolescence. Modern advertising has become more sophisticated, integrating seamlessly into content through native advertising and product placement, making it more difficult to disregard. Additionally, the psychological principles underpinning advertising remain as potent as ever; emotional appeals, social proof, and aspirational messaging continue to shape consumer desires.
In conclusion, although consumers have developed coping mechanisms to filter out overt advertising, I believe that the industry has adapted and transformed, ensuring its continued influence over purchasing behaviour. The question is not whether advertising works, but rather how it works in an increasingly complex media environment.
Why this answer scores Band 7.0:
| Criteria | How the sample meets Band 7.0 requirements |
|---|---|
| Task Response | Clearly addresses both views and provides a personal opinion. Arguments are developed with relevant reasoning and specific examples. |
| Coherence & Cohesion | Clear paragraph structure: introduction → view 1 → view 2 → opinion → conclusion. Uses a range of cohesive devices effectively: On the one hand, Furthermore, On the other hand, Moreover, For example, In my estimation, In conclusion. |
| Lexical Resource | Good range of vocabulary: considerable debate, ubiquity, rendered, pervasiveness, media-saturated, ad fatigue, desensitised, circumvent, sceptical, proliferation, inauthentic, exponential, unprecedented, personalisation, mere exposure effect, obsolescence, sophisticated, underpinning, aspirational, coping mechanisms. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Good variety of complex structures: relative clauses, passive voice, conditional sentences, participle phrases. Occasional minor errors but overall clear and accurate. |
Why this is Band 7.0 (not 7.5 or 6.5):
| Aspect | Band 6.5 | Band 7.0 (this sample) | Band 7.5+ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vocabulary | Adequate | Good range with precision | Wider range with more sophisticated collocations |
| Ideas | Developed | Well-developed with specific examples | More deeply analysed with nuanced connections |
| Examples | General | Specific and relevant | Integrated with deeper analysis |
| Cohesion | Basic connectors | Range of cohesive devices | Seamless and sophisticated |
| Grammar | Mix of simple/complex | Good control, some variety | Confident use of wider range |
| Critical thinking | Clear position | Balanced with some nuance | More sophisticated analysis |
Key features of Band 7.0 demonstrated:
1. Clear introduction with both views and position:
"This essay will discuss both perspectives before concluding that, despite its pervasiveness, advertising continues to exert a significant impact on purchasing decisions."
2. Specific, relevant examples:
"For example, the success of platforms like Google and Meta, whose business models are fundamentally reliant on advertising revenue, demonstrates that brands continue to derive substantial value from such investments."
3. Good range of vocabulary with some sophistication:
media-saturated, ad fatigue, desensitised, circumvent
proliferation, inauthentic, unprecedented, personalisation
mere exposure effect, obsolescence, sophisticated
4. Balanced discussion with clear personal opinion:
"In my estimation, while it is true that traditional forms of advertising may have diminished in impact, advertising as a whole remains extraordinarily effective."
5. Strong conclusion adding value:
"The question is not whether advertising works, but rather how it works in an increasingly complex media environment."
Comparison: Band 6.5 vs 7.0 vs 7.5+
| Aspect | Band 6.5 | Band 7.0 (this sample) | Band 7.5+ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | "Some people think advertising is effective while others disagree. This essay will discuss both views." | "The role of advertising in contemporary society has become a subject of considerable debate. While some argue... others contend... This essay will discuss both perspectives before concluding that..." | More sophisticated opening with nuanced position |
| View 1 example | "Many people ignore ads because they see too many." | "For instance, the proliferation of influencer marketing has made audiences more aware of sponsored content, often causing them to dismiss such endorsements as inauthentic." | Deeper analysis with more specific example |
| View 2 vocabulary | "Advertising is still effective and companies spend lots of money." | "The global advertising industry continues to grow exponentially... the advent of digital advertising has enabled unprecedented levels of personalisation..." | More sophisticated collocations |
| Opinion | "I think advertising still works." | "In my estimation, while it is true that traditional forms of advertising may have diminished in impact, advertising as a whole remains extraordinarily effective. The key distinction lies in the evolution of advertising techniques rather than their obsolescence." | More nuanced with deeper analysis |
| Conclusion | "In conclusion, I believe advertising is still effective." | "The question is not whether advertising works, but rather how it works in an increasingly complex media environment." | Adds insight and forward-thinking perspective |
Quick checklist for Band 7.0+ Task 2 (Discuss Both Views):
- □
Clear introduction with both views and your opinion
- □
One paragraph explaining the first view with examples
- □
One paragraph explaining the second view with examples
- □
One paragraph stating your opinion (can be combined with view 2)
- □
Clear conclusion summarising your position
- □
Each paragraph has a clear topic sentence
- □
Range of linking words used naturally
- □
Good range of vocabulary (not repetitive)
- □
Mix of simple and complex sentences
- □
At least 250-280 words
- □
Few grammatical errors
- □
Formal academic register
Key tips for "Discuss both views and give your opinion" essays:
Structure clearly:
Introduction: Paraphrase + state both views + your position
Body 1: Discuss first view with supporting reasons/examples
Body 2: Discuss second view with supporting reasons/examples
Body 3 (optional): Elaborate on your opinion
Conclusion: Summarise and restate your position
Give equal weight to both views:
Don't spend more time on one view than the other
Use similar length and depth for both
Make your opinion clear throughout:
State it in the introduction
Reinforce it in the body paragraphs
Restate it in the conclusion
Use specific examples:
Name companies, platforms, or real-world phenomena
Make examples relevant to your argument
Use a range of reporting structures:
Some people argue that... / Others contend that...
Proponents of this view claim... / Opponents maintain...
Additional vocabulary for advertising topics:
| Category | Useful words/phrases |
|---|---|
| Types of advertising | print media, digital advertising, influencer marketing, native advertising, product placement, billboards, commercials |
| Consumer response | capture attention, influence behaviour, shape preferences, create desire, brand loyalty, impulse buying |
| Negative views | over-saturation, ad fatigue, desensitised, sceptical, intrusive, manipulative, deceptive |
| Positive views | effective, persuasive, targeted, personalised, engaging, memorable, compelling |
| Techniques | emotional appeal, social proof, aspirational messaging, subliminal, repetition, branding |